UK Rewards vs Cashback
Credit Cards
American Express Preferred Rewards Gold vs
Cashback Everyday
Compare two popular UK credit cards to see how Membership Rewards points and cashback differ. Explore fees, rewards and benefits to find the card that fits your lifestyle.
Search Articles
Choosing between a rewards credit card and a cashback credit card can be confusing, especially when both options offer different ways to get more value from your everyday spending. Some cards allow you to collect points that can be used for travel, shopping and other benefits, while cashback cards return a percentage of your eligible purchases as money.
The right choice depends on how you spend, what benefits you actually use and whether you prefer flexible rewards or straightforward savings. In this guide, we compare two popular UK options: the American Express Preferred Rewards Gold Card and Barclaycard Rewards. We will look at their features, advantages, limitations and the type of cardholder each one may suit.
Table of Contents

Different Reward Styles
Earn Membership Rewards points or cashback on eligible spending.

Find Your Perfect Fit
Compare benefits based on your spending habits.

Side-by-Side Comparison
See key differences at aglance.

Make a Smarter Choice
Choose the card that gives you the most value.
Related Articles
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest credit card guides, tips and offers straight to your
No spam, Unsubscribe anytime
Detailed Comparison
See how American Express Preferred Rewards Gold and Cashback Everyday stack up across key features.
Feature
American Express Preferred Rewards Gold
Barclaycard Rewards
Rewards Type
Membership Rewards points
Reward points (Barclaycard Rewards)
Rewards Rate
Check current offer and terms
Check current offer and terms
Annual Fee
Check current fee and terms
Check current fee and terms
Welcome Offer
Check current welcome offer and terms
Check current welcome offer and terms
Best For
Travelers, flexible rewards and lifestyle benefits
Everyday spending and reward points
Redemption Options
Shopping, gift cards, statement purchases and travel partners
Reward points for travel, shopping and selected partners
Foreign Transaction Fee
Check current foreign currency fees
Check current foreign currency fees
Card Network
American Express
Visa
Additional Perks
Travel-related benefits and selected offers
Rewards programme and selected partner offers
UK Rewards vs Cashback Credit Cards - Pros and Cons
A quick look at what each card does well and where it may not be the best fit.
American Express Preferred Rewards Gold
Pros
Cons
Barclaycard Reward
Pros
Cons
Who Should Choose Which Card?
Your spending habits and lifestyle can help you decide.
Choose American Express Preferred Rewards Gold if...
Choose Barclaycard Rewards if...
For more information about credit cards and how they work, visit MoneyHelper’s guide to credit cards.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between rewards and cashback?
Rewards credit cards earn points that can be redeemed for travel, shopping or other benefits. Cashback credit cards return a percentage of eligible spending as money credited to your account.
Which card is better for everyday spending?
Barclaycard Rewards may suit everyday spending if you prefer earning reward points, while American Express Preferred Rewards Gold may suit you if you value Membership Rewards points and travel-related benefits. Compare the current terms before choosing.
Can I use Membership Rewards points for travel?
Yes. American Express Membership Rewards points can be redeemed through eligible travel options and participating travel partners, subject to the programme’s terms and conditions.
Is American Express Preferred Rewards Gold worth the annual fee?
It depends on how much value you get from its rewards, travel benefits and other perks. Consider whether these benefits justify the annual fee after any introductory offer ends.
Which card is better for beginners?
Barclaycard Rewards may be easier to understand if you prefer earning points on everyday purchases. American Express Preferred Rewards Gold may suit beginners who want flexible rewards and are comfortable managing an annual fee and redemption options.
Still Not Sure?
Compare and Decide Today.
Explore detailed UK credit card comparisons and find the right balance of rewards, cashback and benefits for your lifestyle.